| Platinum | Jimmy John's |
| Platinum | Mancino's Baked Subs & Pizza |
| Platinum | Old Country Sausage German Deli |
| Gold | Blimpie |
| Silver | Firehouse Subs |
| Bronze | Sarah's Bagel Cafe |
| Top Pick | Gyro Shack |
| Top Pick | Idaho Pizza Company |
| Top Pick | Pita Pit |
| Top Pick | Port of Subs |