| Platinum | Idaho Pizza Company |
| Gold | Messenger Pizza & Brewery |
| Silver | Flying Pie Pizzaria |
| Bronze | Messenger LLP |
| Top Pick | Bit of Italy Italiantogo |
| Top Pick | Chicago Connection Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rustic Oven |
| Top Pick | Ruszoni's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Sizzlin' Stone Pizza |
| Top Pick | Smoky Mountain Pizzeria & Grill |