| Platinum | Pollos y Mariscos El Guero |
| Gold | Wheeler's Handout |
| Silver | Dos Caminos Mexican Restaurant |
| Bronze | Jalapeno's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Campos On Lonestar |
| Top Pick | Casa Robles |
| Top Pick | Chapala Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Holy Cow |
| Top Pick | Idaho Pizza Company |
| Top Pick | Red Fort |