| Platinum | Wheeler's Handout |
| Gold | Blazen Burgers |
| Silver | JaK*s Place Neighborhood Grill |
| Bronze | Holy Cow |
| Top Pick | Boise Fry Company BFC |
| Top Pick | Burger Theory |
| Top Pick | Red Robin Gourmet Burgers |
| Top Pick | The Drop Zone |
| Top Pick | Whiskey River |
| Top Pick | Whitehouse Drive In |